The committee that wrote the report found that the proposed broadening of USGCRP's scope to address not only climate change but also other climate-related global changes is appropriate and an important step. However, the committee said, "the draft plan does not always acknowledge significant challenges, such as increasingly constrained budget resources, involved in meeting its goals, nor does it offer clear strategies for how such challenges could be addressed. There is also the practical challenge of maintaining clear boundaries for an expanded program."
The committee emphasized the need to identify initial steps the program would take to achieve the proposed broadening of its scope, develop critical science capacity that is now lacking, and link the production of knowledge to its use. It also stressed that without a strong governance structure that could compel reallocation of funds to serve overarching priorities, the program would likely continue as merely a compilation of efforts deriving from each member agency's individual priorities.
Broadening the program to better integrate the social and ecological sciences, inform climate change mitigation and adaptation efforts, and emphasize decision support is welcome and essential for meeting the legislative mandate for the program, the committee said. Nevertheless, implementing this wider scope requires more than incremental solutions. For instance, there is insufficient expertise within member agencies in the social and ecological sciences, and some agencies lack clear mandates to develop the needed expertise.
The report also suggests that the USGCRP plan could be strengthened by:
- offering a more coherent summary of past important accomplishments, including an assessment of successes that were possible only because of USGCRP actions;
- establishing clear processes for setting priorities and phasing in and out elements of the program;
- employing iterative processes for periodically evaluating and updating the program and its priorities; and
- more carefully defining the education, communication, and work-force development efforts that belong within the program and which efforts would be best organized by entities outside the program.
The report emphasizes that, "The Plan says that the decisions being made today about systems affected by global change
Access a release from NAS (click here). Access the complete NAS 72-page report from NAS (click here). Access an announcement from USGCRP (click here). Access more information about the U.S. Carbon Cycle Science Program (click here). Access the complete 81-page Strategy (click here). [#Climate]
GET THE REST OF TODAY'S NEWS (click here)